Macdonald | Fernandez LLP

MACDONALD | FERNANDEZ LLP


221 Sansome Street
San Francisco, CA 94104
Telephone: (415) 362-0449
Facsimile: (415) 394-5544
914 Thirteenth Street
Modesto, CA 95354
Telephone: (209)549-7949
Facsimile: (209) 236-0172

Orchard Supply Hardware Files Chapter 11 Bankruptcy

Orchard Supply Hardware Stores Corp. has commenced a chapter 11 bankruptcy case in Delaware (Case No. 13-11565).  The company spun off from Sears Holdings Corp. in 2011, and blames burdensome payments owed to Sears as the reason for reorganizing.  Lowe's is set to serve as stalking horse bidder to buy 60 of OSH's 91 California stores with a bid of $205 million.

Judgment Awarding Value of Withdrawing Member's Interest in an LLC Subordinated

In O'Donnell v. Tristar Esperanza Properties, LLC, BAP No. CC-12-1340-KIPaDu (9th Cir. BAP Mar. 8, 2013), the Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel held that a judgment awarding the value of a withdrawing member's interest in a limited liability company is vulnerable to mandatory subordination under Bankruptcy Code Section 510(b) as damages arising from the purchase or sale of a security.

Jane O'Donnell withdrew her 14% membership interest in Tristar Esperanza Properties, LLC.  Pursuant to the operating  agreement, O'Donnell hired an appraiser, who estimated the value of her interest to be $399,918.  Tristar objected; O'Donnell brought an arbitration and obtained an award for $399,918 less $60,000 previously received.  The award was confirmed and a judgment was entered.

Tristar filed a chapter 11 bankruptcy case  and an adversary proceeding to subordinate O'Donnell's claim.  The debtor prevailed, and the BAP affirmed.

Although a membership interets in an LLC is not among the enumerated examples of a "security" under Bankruptcy Code Section 101(49), the BAP reasoned that it is analogous to "the interest of a limited partner in a limited liability partnership."  The BAP also analyzed the legislative history of Section 510(b) and prior cases, and held that O'Donnell's withdrawal was "nothing other than her cashing out her equity (at a value that the Debtor insists is highly inflated)."

The scope of the BAP's broad view of what constitutes a claim arising from the purchase or sale of a debtor's securities. Any claim with a nexus or causal relationship with a transaction involving securities may be subject to mandatory subordination.


Stockton to Pay $5.1 Million to Settle Health Benefit Claims

In the chapter 9 bankruptcy of Stockton, California, the city will pay $5.1 million in a settlement with retired employees on account of lost health benefits.  The settlement is part of the city's reprganization plan.  The settlement tepresents 2% of the value of the lost benefits, but it preserves their pensions.  The retirees will have the opportunity to vote on the plan.  

MF Global Creditors Could Receive 94% Recovery

MF Global Inc.’s former customers may receive more than 94 cents on the dollar, an outstanding return in a bankruptcy liquidation.  Most have already recovered 89 percent of their claims. The additional recoveries depend in part upon finalizing settlements with MF Global’s U.K. office and JPMorgan Chase.  Litigation against officers and directors, including Jon Corzine, will also affect the size and timing of the distribution. http://tinyurl.com/llcmows

Appointment to National Conference of Bankruptcy Judges Next Generation Program

We are pleased to announce that Reno Fernandez has been selected for the National Conference of Bankruptcy Judges Next Generation Program for 2013.  Attorneys from our firm will be attending the conference October 30 through November 2, 2013, in Atlanta, Georgia.

Bankruptcy Crimes

Join Reno Fernandez, Chair of the Bar Association of San Francisco's Commercial Law & Bankruptcy Section, for this white-linen lunch program:

BANKRUPTCY CRIMES
Tuesday, June 11, 2013
Noon to 1:30 pm

Speakers 

Hon. Stephen L. Johnson, Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division

Joseph Fazioli, Assistant U.S. Attorney, U.S. Department of Justice 

Jeffrey L. Bornstein, Partner, K&L Gates

Emily S. Keller, Trial Attorney, U.S. Trustee’s Office

Moderator

Ivo Keller, Associate, Buchalter Nemer

Topics

• A discussion of the intersection between the bankruptcy code and criminal law

• How attorneys should respond when they see evidence of potential criminal conduct

• Considerations affecting public prosecutors’ handling of allegations of fraud and other crimes in bankruptcy cases


Location


Le Meridien Hotel
333 Battery Street
San Francisco, CA 

Please RSVP to: http://tinyurl.com/oc3gbuw

Thank you for supporting the Section.  See you there!

Macdonald | Fernandez LLP Congratulates the California Bankruptcy Forum on 25 Years of Excellence!

We are happy to be attending the California Bankruptcy Forum's Insolvency Conference, which kicks off today.  Congratulations to the CBF on its 25th anniversary!